Metacritic's 2025's Top 10 Worst Games: A Tale of Disagreement and Surprises
The holiday season is upon us, and with it comes the annual tradition of ranking the year's best and worst in various categories. Metacritic, a renowned aggregator of game reviews, has recently unveiled its list of the 10 worst video games of 2025, based on professional critic scores. However, an intriguing twist emerges when we consider the opinions of regular players.
The Critics' Verdict
The list, as determined by gaming journalists, opens with Fast & Furious: Arcade Edition (45 points), followed by Scar-Lead Salvation, QUByte Classics: Glover, and Ambulance Life: A Paramedic Simulator, each scoring 44 points. Tamagotchi Plaza (43 points), Gore Doctor (40 points), and Spy Drops (39 points) also made the cut. The lowest-rated game, Blood of Mehran (38 points), an action RPG from Permanent Way Game, rounds out the bottom three. The dubious honor of the worst game of the year goes to MindsEye, an action-adventure game from Build a Rocket Boy, scoring a mere 28 points.
A Different Perspective: User Scores
When we shift our focus to user scores, the list takes an unexpected turn. EA Sports College Football 26 (4.4/10) takes the 10th spot, followed by Madden NFL 26 (3.9/10), Tales of the Shire (3.8/10), Sid Meier's Civilization VII, Destiny 2: The Edge of Fate, and Nintendo Switch 2 Welcome Tour (all 3.7/10). EA Sports FC 26 (2.9/10) and Football Manager 26 (2.6/10) complete the list. Interestingly, MindsEye drops to second place with a 2.5/10 rating, while Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 (1.6/10) takes the top spot, becoming one of the lowest-rated games in the past 25 years.
The Debate Continues
These contrasting lists highlight the subjective nature of game reviews. While professional critics may have different criteria, regular players often have unique perspectives. The article invites readers to share their thoughts on the lists and their personal worst games of 2025 in the comments section.
For more gaming insights and the latest industry news, follow 80 Level's social media channels: Newsletter, Talent platform, Twitter, LinkedIn, Telegram, and Instagram.
